Let's face it: there are ALOT of big bats in Major League
baseball, Jose Altuve, Bryce Harper and Aaron Judge just to name a few.
Unfortunately, in the era of launch angle and exit velocity, the art of
hitting-real hitting-is disappearing. Batting titles and on-base percentage is out,
and home run crowns are in.
This is the era of
baseball we live in, and it's a bad one. Don't get me wrong, I love home runs.
They're exciting, but not at the expense of the most fundamental thing in the
game-the base hit. The most puzzling thing about this launch angle era of
baseball is the idea that "strikeouts don't matter". Young players
are willing to sacrifice average and on-base percentage for strikeouts as long
as they're hitting bombs. The fundamental flaw of this theory is that baseball
doesn't have a clock. Baseball has outs-27 of them to be exact. A finite,
unmoving number. A strikeout takes one of those outs away. If you reach that
27th out and you're trailing, that's it. Base hits extend games, extend innings,
extend winning streaks. Strikeouts don't. Aaron Judge, Cody Bellinger and
Giancarlo Stanton are exciting for sure. They combined for 150 homers in
2017....but they also combined for 517 strikeouts. That's a lot of outs...more
than 19 full games worth in case you were wondering.
Base hits aren't
sexy anymore, but they win games and win championships. The players that still
recognize that deserve to be recognized. Some hitters catch our attention, like
former MVPs Buster Posey and Joe Mauer, but others don't. So, I've done my
research and come up with what I believe are the ten most underrated and
underappreciated hitters in all of Major League baseball. The main criteria for getting your name on this list is not having been recognized with awards, so Joey Votto's MVP, Daniel Murphy's NLCS MVP and Joe Mauer's hitting title rule them out. Let's dive in:
10. Brandon Belt- San Francisco Giants
Brandon Belt is a
2-time World Series champion with the San Francisco Giants at was a central
part in his team's ability to attain the ultimate price in both 2012 and 2014.
Belt's raw stats may not blow you away, but the career .270 hitter gets on base
a lot. Drawing a lot of walks and posting a career OBP of.361 insures that his
is on base for his teammate and 2012 NL Buster Posey to drive him in. One
immeasurable stat that Belt possesses is his plate presence. His 6-foot 4, 235-pound
frame is tough for any pitcher to overlook. Belt's bat is biggest when it
matters most, posting a .308 average in the 2014 World Series. Hitting isn't
always flashy and Brandon Belt proves that, but it is always productive.
9. Scooter Gennett- Cincinnati Reds
|
Gennett: 4 HRs & 10 RBIs on June 6,
2017 vs. Cardinals
|
Gennett broke into the league in 2013 with Milwaukee and has
a career average of .289. Only once in his career has Gennett had an on-base
percentage (OBP) lower than .300 (and it was .294), and so far in 2018 he is
top-5 in the entire MLB in both hits and batting average. But don't think he doesn't
have any power. He hit a career-high 27 home runs in 2017, including four in
one game. Gennett has proven he knows how to hit in this league.
8. Nick Castellanos- Detroit Tigers
Castellanos may
not be a well-known name in the league, but that may be because he has spent
his entire career hitting in the (literal) shadow of one of the MLB's all-time
greats, Miguel Cabrera. For the last couple of years though, Cabrera has
battled injuries and Castellanos has had to carry a less-than-stellar Detroit Tigers
offense alone, and he's done a pretty good job considering that Detroit has
been in full rebuild mode since their 2012 World Series appearance.
Surprisingly though, the 2018 Tigers find themselves very much in the AL
Central division race and Castellanos is a major reason why. He is hitting .307
with 41 RBIs so far. Even though he struggled to find his place in the league
when he was called up in 2013, Castellanos has managed to rebound for a career
average of .272. He is also on pace for career-highs in batting average, hits,
runs scored and doubles in 2018. Castellanos is definitely under-appreciated.
7. Anthony Rendon- Washington Nationals
|
Rendon: 6-6, 10 RBIs on May 30,
2017 vs Mets
|
Anthony Rendon is on
this list for one major reason: the Washington Nationals are stacked on
offense. That's definitely a good thing if you're Rendon, but the problem is
that no one talks about Rendon's bat with all those others around. Rendon is
consistent and dangerous....when he's on the field. 2018 is Rendon's 6th big
league season and in the five years prior, he has only played for than 100
games three times (2014, 2016, 2017). So, he's a bit injury prone, but in those
three seasons-where he played in 153, 156 and 147 games respectively-Rendon has
managed to rack up more than 150 hits, 80 RBIs, 38 doubles and 80 runs in those
seasons, and he's projected to do it again in 2018. He even collected Comeback
Player of the Year honors in 2016. While Rendon won't put up Bryce Harper's
power numbers, he possesses something that many players don't-the clutch gene.
He has a reputation for coming up with the big hits when Washington needs them.
In a game against the division rival Mets on April 30th, 2017, Rendon delivered
in a big way. He went 6 for 6 at the plate, hitting 3 homers and driving in 10
runs! Tell me you wouldn't want that guy on your team.
6. J.T. Realmuto-Miami Marlins
Prior to the 2018
season, new owner Derek Jeter blew up the Marlins existing roster, and when the
smoke cleared, Realmuto was seemingly all that was left from the 2017 Marlins
offense. As the default leader of the now-depleted Marlins club, Realmuto
hasn't wavered. He has posted a .300 average with 9 homers and 27 RBIs, which
is especially impressive when you consider that he's only played in 53 of
Miami's 74 games, since he's a catcher and they don't play every day. Realmuto
is young, and won't blow you away with power, but he's consistent and not
afraid to take his walks, giving him a career OBP of .327. Given that he shared
a lineup card with Giancarlo Stanton up until 2017, getting on base with that
guy coming to the plate counted for a lot.
5. Brandon Nimmo-New York Mets
|
Nimmo: Drafted 13th overall in 2011
from American Legion ball.
|
When crafting my
list, I had one pretty hard and fast rule: the players needed to have plenty of
big league experience. That meant no rookies or sophomores because it's hard to
tell with those guys if they're just that good, or if opposing pitchers just
haven't figured them out yet. But after watching him play, I knew I had to make
an exception for the Mets' Brandon Nimmo. In his short career, spanning only
161 games, Nimmo has proven himself not only to be a threat in New York's
lineup, but as a picture of health on a roster otherwise ravaged with injuries.
His constant presence and production for the Mets is a bright spot in a roller
coaster season for New York. I know this choice is suspect given his limited
service time, but trust me, the kid can play. The most impressive thing about
this guy is his story. Growing up in Wyoming, the cold weather meant that his
high school didn't have a baseball program, so Nimmo played American Legion
ball. Traveling all around the country to play high school baseball, Nimmo was
discovered by the Mets and drafted him in 2011. Not having a "home
team" in high school tells me one thing: Nimmo is adaptable, which is
valuable in any league. He gets on base a ton, posting a career OBP of .385
(.409 in 2018) and he can run, already putting up 26 extra base hits in 2018....including
5 triples, good enough for fourth in the MLB. He may not have the numbers yet,
but you're going to have to trust me, he's going to.
4. Nick Markakis- Atlanta Braves
This was a
difficult choice, not because Nick Markakis doesn't deserve to be on this list,
because he definitely does, but because he has a couple of teammates that
deserve to be too. Along with my rule about service time, my only other rule
for making this list was that I didn't want to have multiple players from the
same team. However, it's worth mentioning that both Freddie Freeman and Ender
Inciarte could've made this list. Freeman, who in a recent ESPN article was
called "criminally underrated" is a career .293 hitter with 635 RBIs
in 8 seasons and is arguably the best opposite field hitter in the game today.
Inciarte is a on-base machine, posting career marks at a .290 average and a
.337 OBP. He's gotten 150 or more hits each of the last three
seasons-collecting 201 hits in 2017, good enough for the 3rd highest mark in
the MLB-and is on pace to reach that mark again in 2018. With competition like that on his own team,
you know Markakis is good. Only once in his 12-year career has Markakis had
less than 170 in a season where he's played at least 145 games, and that was
his rookie year. In 2018, at the age of 34 Markakis may be having his best
season ever. In the National League, Markakis has the league lead in hits,
ranks in the top 5 for batting average and doubles, 6th in OBP, 10th in RBIs,
and he's a tough man to set down on strikes, leading all of Major League
Baseball in plate appearances per strikeout. The thing that sets Markakis apart
from his teammates is this: Markakis is the elder of this list playing 12-big
league seasons with Baltimore and Atlanta and amassing 2100 career hits. He's
one of the best right fielders in the game, both offensively and defensively
and is a poster child for playing every day, playing less than 147 games only
once in his career. Despite all of this, Markakis has never been selected to an
All-Star Game. That is the definition of underrated. Do the right thing this
summer: help get Nick Markakis to the 2018 MLB All-Star Game.
3. Mookie Betts- Boston Red Sox
|
Betts: Has two 3-HR games in 2018 |
If I was making
this list next year, this guy probably wouldn't be on it. When I started this
process, the 2018 season hadn't started yet. Mookie Betts is likely going to
win the 2018 AL MVP Award, so I guess he's proving me right. Premonitions of
future success aren't new to me. At the start of the 2011 season, while he was
solid, yet still relatively unknown, I told a friend of mine that Clayton
Kershaw would win the NL Cy Young that season, which he did...and two more
after that. Markus Lynn "Mookie" Betts is having the best year of his
young career, but the 25-year old id no stranger to this level of success. He
has a career batting average of .296, the highest of anyone on this list. In
his four seasons prior to 2018, he drove in 100 runs twice, played in at least
145 games three times, had at least 165 hits three times and hit at least .290 three times. In
2018, he is likely going to set career highs in both batting average and home
runs, currently hitting .336 with 18 bombs. Again, if I'm making this list in
2019, Mookie's probably not on it since this is about underrated hitters, just
like if I had made this list prior to the 2017 season, Charlie Blackmon, Justin
Turner, and Daniel Murphy probably would've made appearances. Being underrated
only lasts for so long when you're this good.
2. Christian Yelich- Milwaukee Brewers
Just like his
former teammate J.T. Realmuto, Christian Yelich was overshadowed for years in
Miami by Giancarlo Stanton, despite being far and away the best pure HITTER on
the team. It wasn't until the last year or so when fans started to notice how
good a hitter Yelich actual is, but he did manage to earn a Silver Slugger
Award as Stanton's teammate in 2016. In his five years, Yelich has never had an
average lower than .282, not even in his rookie season. Yelich has been a good
hitter from the jump in this league, collecting 790 hits with a .291 average by
his age 26 season. He drives in runs and has good speed, collecting 30 or more
doubles in each of his last four seasons. Yelich is finally getting the
recognition he deserves, earning an offseason trade to the new-look Milwaukee
Brewers, where he, along with All-Star outfielder Lorenzo Cain, has staked
claim to the first place spot in the tightly-contested NL Central Division.
Yelich is one of the best, most underappreciated hitters on this list and in
the league, and he's only 26.
1. A.J. Pollock- Arizona Diamondbacks
|
Pollock: Hit over .300 in consecutive
years (2014, 2015)
|
The top spot comes
with a grain of salt. A.J. Pollock is truly one of my favorite players in the
entire league. He can out-hit anyone...when he's healthy. Yes, that is his
Achilles heel and it's a big one. Pollock has missed a ton of time for the
Diamondbacks in his career, but when it's in the lineup, his bat is something
special. He has a career batting average
of .293 and an OBP of .349. To give you an idea how good Pollock is and how
highly Arizona thinks of him, consider this: at the 2015 MLB Winter Meetings
the Diamondbacks traded Dansby Swanson to the Atlanta Braves for pitcher Shelby
Miller. You're probably thinking "What does this have to do with A.J.
Pollock?" Pollock was going into his fifth season in Arizona, but he was
starting to feel the heat from a second year player breathing down his neck in
center field. In order to ease the pressure, the D-Backs traded that second
year player to Atlanta, essentially as a throw-in piece in the Dansby Swanson
trade. That player's name: Ender Inciarte. You know, the guy I mentioned above
who had 201 hits in 2017 and was getting NL MVP considerations? The same guy
who, oh by the way, has one two consecutive Gold Gloves in Atlanta and is well
on his way to a third, all the while Pollock has missed 233 of Arizona's 397
team games since the trade. The Diamondbacks were confident enough in Pollock
to let Inciarte go, and for good reason. As I said, when he's healthy, he's
dangerous. While this spot on the list may read more like a scathing retort of
the injury-plagued center fielder or a ringing endorsement for his former
battery mate, I assure you it isn't. It is a plea for him to get healthy
because I believe he is one of the best hitters in this game. Wait and see.
There you have it: my top 10 most underrated hitters. Let me know what you think of the list. Who are your top 10? Let's debate this. One thing that's not up for debate is that the art of hitting needs to come back in style. Also, let me know what other top 10 lists you'd like to see. See y'all around!